Welcome! | Ask A Question

 
 
 
 
Question

Asked 4/21/2008

Why does my age group get double dipped on retirement?

I ask you. Why is it that the age group of 35 and under seem to be double billed for retirement. Why is it we have to pay into Social Security if we are never going to reap any benefit from it?

Meanwhile, we're paying into 401k because we're told it's the only way we're going to have any retirement funds. Yes, my grandparents are alive and get a small pittence from SS, and I feel sorta bad asking. But why are we paying for something we're constantly being told we'll never recieve.

Why can't we "cash out" so to speak and start taking those dollars we would put towards SS into our own retirement funds? Why do we have to pay double? Shouldn't the money that our grandparents paid in have grown and been enough to carry them into retirement? I know people are living longer now, and they have to be taken care of but still seems unfair to burden people who had nothing to do with the loss of funds.

 
 
 
 
 
 
Answers

Answer 1/6 - Submitted 4/21/2008

I would be happy to just get back the FICA contributions I've made thus far (that includes employer contributions), I've had a job since I was 14. I'll gladly take it know and invest it. But I'm sure glad you will be there at you maximal earning capacity in 20 years when I start to collect what I am due!

 
 

Answer 2/6 - Submitted 4/21/2008

If you believe political speak then you are in for a rough ride, Social Security is not in danger. the voting public will not let it happen.!~!

 
 

Answer 3/6 - Submitted 4/21/2008

If congress had listened to the president, you would have a choice about social security, but congress felt you did not know how to handle your money, therefore they refused to make the change to allow you to choose. As to your other retirement plans, stay with it because congress is constantly borrowing money from social security and adding groups of people that can draw from it, but have never paid into it. Then you have to consider that people are living longer and that the senor citizens numbers are increasing. Most likely by the time you are eligible, there will not be any social security left.

 
 

Answer 4/6 - Submitted 4/21/2008

The SS payments you and your generation make are to support you parents and grandparents in their retirement, since too many of one generation were unwilling to support them directly. The programs were established to prevent armed insurrection in the country in the 1930's. This was caused by the republican abuse of the banking system in the 1920's.
This is not double dipping, you can opt out of the 401 K programs by only letting the minimum contribution be made by your employer. Part of your problem is you believe what the Republican scaremongers have been pumping in to the public for 20 years.

 
 

Answer 5/6 - Submitted 4/21/2008

Thank your democratic congressional leaders for it.

 
 

Answer 6/6 - Submitted 4/21/2008

In my opinion it's people like Hillary and Obama telling you that the government knows what is best for you and what to do with your money.

Personally I would rather they give me the money the government takes out for social security and let me invest it in what I think is the best investment opportunity for me.

 
 
 
 

Related Questions (Ask a New Question)

 
401k contribution in the year i reach full retirement age?

I will reach full retirement age in june 09 and will continue to work but will apply for social security benefits in june. how much can i contibute to my 401k plan in calendar 09? is there any limitation as long as i continue to work?

See Answers

 
Early retirement withdrawal

I'm not sure if my plan is a 401k. my employer contributes money each year, not me. i am having some serious job related problems. if i leave my job now, (i will be 59&1/2, in three weeks, is there a penalty for getting my money before i reach retirement age?

See Answers

 
I took out a 401k loan default?

I took out a 401k loan at my company and paid on it for a couple of years. i found a new job and they told me that unless i could pay it all off in 1 lump sum i had to default. i paid the penalties and the taxes for defaulting my loan and worked for the other company for close to a year. my former...

See Answers

 
Related Questions

401k contribution in the year i reach full retirement age?


I will reach full retirement age in june 09 and will continue to work but will apply for social...

 

Early retirement withdrawal


I'm not sure if my plan is a 401k. my employer contributes money each year, not me. i...

 

I took out a 401k loan default?


I took out a 401k loan at my company and paid on it for a couple of years. i found a new...

 

Additional retirement programs


If i participate in a 401k program where i work, am i allowed to invest in other form of retirement...

 

401k and withdraws


My husband is retired and has his retirement managed by an investment group. what are the...

 
 
 

See more 401k questions

 
 
 
 
 

Ask A Question

Ask a new question about
401k: