Welcome! | Ask A Question

 
 
 
 
Question

Asked 4/12/2008

Would allowing a one time limited amount withdrawal from 401k plans without penalties be helpful to economy?

In the present economy, what would be the impact of allowing folk a one time withdrawal from their 401k plans without the penalties to pay down debt, catch up behind payments, do home repair or to make targeted purchases to help stimultate the economy. I'm thinking a maximun of 20% of their present balance. And write into law that this can only be done during national emergencies and only in 10 year time spans.

 
 
 
 
 
 
Answers

Answer 1/3 - Submitted 4/12/2008

Doesn't that just delay the problem - so instead of not having any money now, you don't have any money for later in life? The problem I see with it is that it does not force people to take responsibility for their finances now. If you are living beyond your means, you need to come up with a plan and budget to live with the money you make. People are so used to having everything that sacrifice, work, and budgeting are forgotten concepts. It may not be easy now, but if everyone who are having these issues addresses the probelm and takes responsibility, it will only help in the long run. Bailing people out in the short term does no good.

 
 

Answer 2/3 - Submitted 4/12/2008

Vegas - I agree with you to a extent. But something does need to be done quickly. You have people like myself, who do live within our means, who are feeling the brunt of this weakened economy (not a recession according to the government). I don't know what the solution is, but the people who over-extended themselves should NOT be receiving any aid. People who did this and the money hungry lenders are the reason we are having the problems we are having.
As to the answer to the question, I vote NO. The people who are causing this probably do NOT 401's in place, thereby it would be enabling them to make even more bad decisions, as the stable people would be the ones trying to fix the economy. I shouldn't have to take from my 401k to fix what someone else caused. Sorry, but I already pay enough for those who don't want to work.

 
 

Answer 3/3 - Submitted 4/13/2008

Besides, most people won't 'pay down debt, catch up behind payments, do home repair or to make targeted purchases'. They will just buy more junk, go to more casinos, take on more debt. In a month they will have used up all the 'new' money and be even worse off later. (Anything you can write into law, you can re-write. If it suits some politician, there'll be a 'national emergency' every 6 months.)

 
 
 
 

Related Questions (Ask a New Question)

 
I paid almost $3k in penalties for early withdrawal on my 401k in 2010 for my 2009 taxes. can that amount of penalties be ded...

On my 2009 tax return i incurred a $2943.00 penalty for early withdrawal of my 401k ( i was and still am unemployed) can i deduct that amount as an expense on my 2010 return?

See Answers

 
Is the penalty paid on early withdrawal of a 401k tax deductible

We had to withdraw our 401k due to financial problems,we did not claim hardship because it is so hard to do and now i have received a tax form showing the total amount of the 401k but not the actual amount we received. do i have to claim the total amount even though we only received a little over half...

See Answers

 
Taxes & penalties on 401k withdrawal

I was laid off from my job on sept 1st of this year. i had 3 loans against my 401k which total approx $7341. i do not have the money to repay these loans, so i'm assuming that i will have to pay taxes and penalties on that amount for this year. i have a new job, but my income has been significantly...

See Answers

 
Related Questions

I paid almost $3k in penalties for early withdrawal on my 401k in 2010 for my 2009 taxes. can that amount of penalties be ded...


On my 2009 tax return i incurred a $2943.00 penalty for early withdrawal of my 401k ( i was...

 

Is the penalty paid on early withdrawal of a 401k tax deductible


We had to withdraw our 401k due to financial problems,we did not claim hardship because it...

 

Taxes & penalties on 401k withdrawal


I was laid off from my job on sept 1st of this year. i had 3 loans against my 401k which...

 

Early hardship withdrawals


I took a hardship withdrawal out of my 401k last december of 2007 to provide the amount needed...

 

401k loan payment


My husband had a outstanding loan on his 401k. he took out another 401k loan and used part...

 

I took out a 401k loan for $15,000 and a week later they stated i could not take a loan out because i had 1 out and they repo...


I applied and completed the loan on their website and they sent me the loan papers, however,...

 
 

See more 401k questions

 
 
 
 
 

Ask A Question

Ask a new question about
401k: