Welcome! | Ask A Question

 
 
 
 
Question

Asked 10/22/2007

Can I transfer my company 401K savings to a ROTH 401K w/o penalty?

Im just not getting the returns I would expect from the 401K plan I have with my company and feel I could benefit from rolling over the money into something else. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. I want to do this without incurring any penalties.Thanks

 
 
 
 
 
 
Answers

Answer 1/5 - Submitted 10/22/2007

No you cannot. The funds you put into your 401k were pre-tax dollars and funds into a Roth are after-tax dollars. You would incur early withdrawal penalties from the IRS and most likely from the 401k fund company. There are also strict rules on when and why you can withdraw from a 401k prior to retirement.

 
 

Answer 2/5 - Submitted 10/22/2007

Actually..

Here's a link.
Looks like the only thing you can convert to a ROTH IRA is a traditional IRA.

 
 

Answer 3/5 - Submitted 10/23/2007

There is something called a Roth 401k. You would have to ask your company's benefits person if they are willing to change from the traditional 401k that they presently have to a Roth 401k. Each paticipant in the plan would have to recharacterize their present 401k accounts into a Roth 401k account. Which would mean paying all the taxes now. This might make sense for some employees but not all. Are you prepared to come up with the money to pay your taxes now out of your own pocket? If you are not happy with the returns you are getting perhaps its the fund choices you are making or perhaps its the Fund company itself. You might want to speak with the powers that be to see if they need to look a new plan sponser.

 
 

Answer 4/5 - Submitted 10/23/2007

You could roll your 401K into an Roth IRA in another investment company BUT you must pay taxes on all that money during that transaction. Remember you have deferred all of those taxes in your 401K up to this point. Once this money goes into your Roth you do not have to pay anymore taxes on your interest you acquire.

 
 

Answer 5/5 - Submitted 10/23/2007

Does your company offer the ROTH option? If not, Unless you have your own business that has income then a ROTH 401k is not an option period...a 401k has to be offered by an employer. As for rolling out money while you're still employed? That's only an option for a very few plans and only for employer contributed money. Any money you put into the plan has to stay there until you turn age 59 1/2 or you separate from service (quit or get fired).

If you're not happy with the returns then go to your boss and tell him..perhaps there are better options for your 401(k). Though the market recently hasn't been very good so likely that's the culprit more than the investments. Without knowing what options you have (fund names and class) I couldn't even comment about the quality.

 
 
 
 

Related Questions (Ask a New Question)

 
401k rollover to roth ira with agi limit

I have a 401k from a previous employer that i want to convert into a roth ira. unfortunately i am not eligible to contribute based on income limits above 120k. it seems the rules changed in 2010 and allow the conversion, but not contributions without first contributing to another ira? i need help...

See Answers

 
Can i avoid 10% penalty on 401k loan considered an early withdrawal when company shut down?

I had taken out a 401k loan a couple years ago and was repaying systematically. in january 2009, my company was sold and went out of business and the 401k program was terminated and accounts rolled over into personal ira rollovers. the remaining balance of the 401k loan has been treated as an early...

See Answers

 
Loan on 401k, layed off by company, can't repay loan so it will be a distribution, 10 penalty

My wife was just layed off after 15 yrs employment. we have a loan against her 401k. the company that handles the 401k says we cannot continue payments, only option is to pay off (can't do) or they let it go into default and make it a distribution. i read that as she is over 55 (57) a distibution...

See Answers

 
Related Questions

401k rollover to roth ira with agi limit


I have a 401k from a previous employer that i want to convert into a roth ira. unfortunately...

 

Can i avoid 10% penalty on 401k loan considered an early withdrawal when company shut down?


I had taken out a 401k loan a couple years ago and was repaying systematically. in january...

 

Loan on 401k, layed off by company, can't repay loan so it will be a distribution, 10 penalty


My wife was just layed off after 15 yrs employment. we have a loan against her 401k. the...

 

Where to transfer a 401k into?


I was laid off a few months ago. i had a 401k with the company and will have to transfer it...

 

My current company is being sold, do i have to transfer my 401k from the old company into the new company?


My current company is being sold, do i have to transfer my 401k from the old company into...

 

Can i take my 401k with me?


My company is offering a 401k through morningstar with a small matching amount. i was wondering...

 
 

See more 401k questions

 
 
 
 
 

Ask A Question

Ask a new question about
401k: