Welcome! | Ask A Question

 
 
 
 
Question

Asked 11/14/2006

Individual 401k - Solo 401k - SEP IRA?

I've recently become self employed and have a 401k at my old job. I just started doing research on self employed retirement plans like the SEP IRA and individual 401k. I found some good information about them here http://www.individual401k.com

From reading information about them the Individual 401k and SEP have the same limits $44,000 but with the individual 401k you might be able to contribute more at "identical income levels". Here is a quote from their website.

"Compared to other retirement plans you may be able to make greater contributions at identical income levels, therefore maximizing retirement contributions and valuable tax deductions."

Has anyone else set one of these retirement plans up? Should I setup a SEP IRA instead of an Individual 401k? What are the main things I should be considering when I make my decision?

Thank you for any information you can provide about the SEP IRA or Individual 401k to someone who is self employed.
JT

 
 
 
 
 
 
Answers

Answer 1/3 - Submitted 11/14/2006

you should invest in cd's instead, being you are your own employer now..its not like you can match what you put in every week so its pointless, or a locked in savings account with interest

 
 

Answer 2/3 - Submitted 11/17/2006

Here's a pretty good article:
http://www.smartmoney.com/taxmatters/index.cfm?sto ry=20021031

There seem to be 2 main advantages of the Solo 401k:
- Ability to borrow against it
- Ability to make a larger tax-deductible contribution to the plan

 
 

Answer 3/3 - Submitted 11/20/2006

JT this is probably what you need to help you. It explains the differences pretty clearly.

http://www.taxalmanac.org/index.php/SEP_IRA_versus _Solo_401k_/_Individual_401k

SEP IRA versus Solo 401k / Individual 401k

Introduction:

Are you still recommending a SEP IRA as a retirement plan to your self employed clients? I'm guilty of that too until I learned about how some of my clients could benefit from the Individual 401k (sometimes called a Solo 401k) as an alternative to a SEP IRA. A SEP IRA is a good choice for some self employed clients, but in other situations an Individual 401k provides a larger contribution / tax deduction versus a SEP IRA

About the Topic:

Individual 401k / Solo 401k plans are available to sole props, LLC and S and C corps. The advantage is in how the contributions are calculated. Also, a client that has an Individual 401k can have a loan, something they can not have in a SEP IRA. For example, I have had a client that left an employer and had a 401k, rolled over their 401k into an Individual 401k and then borrowed $50,000 to finance the startup of his business. There are no income or credit qualifications of getting the loan and interest is paid back into their own 401k.

Contributions SEP IRA versus Individual 401k / Solo 401k

In the example below the client is age 55 will have $100,000 net income in 2006 as a sole prop.

SEP IRA - max contribution would be $18,587

Individual 401k - max contribution would be $20,000 + $18,587 = $38,587.

Before I knew of the benefits of the Individual 401k I would have recommended a SEP IRA and would have left a $20,000 tax deduction on the table.

Not every client can make a contribution greater than the $18,587 permitted in a SEP IRA in this example, but for those clients that can an Individual 401k is clearly more advantageous. Also, a very interesting point is the benefits can be doubled for a husband and wife both working for the business and each with 100k net income would be able to contribute a total of $77,174 to an Individual 401k.

Summary:

An Individual 401k may provide your clients with a greater tax deduction and retirement contribution when compared to a SEP IRA. Also, an Individual 401k allows a loan that can provide a financial cushion or can help finance the startup of the business. I have had clients setup retirement account at this firm and have become knowledgeable about these retirement plans by reading the information on http://www.individual401k.com

 
 
 
 

Related Questions (Ask a New Question)

 
Investment question!

If you move money out of a 401k and into an ira and you make no changes to the stocks you have, does the money grow at the same rate with the ira as it did with the 401k? also, what are the benefits of an ira over a 401k. in addition, what is the difference in a roth ira and a traditional ira.

See Answers

 
Paying off loan by rolling over to 401k to ira

The sale of my company will be going through very soon. i already have a $2000 loan on my 401k loan that i want to pay off when i rollover into an ira. i am in need of some extra cash and would like to take out another $2000 before the sale. can i have 2 loans on my 401k at one time? will i be able...

See Answers

 
My new employer doesn't have a 401k. i already had a roth and an existing ira. which one should i fully fund now?

I was recently laid-off and my prospective employer doesn't currently offer a 401k (may in the near future). in addition to the above question, will the 401k rollover be considered part of the yearly ira contribution and if so, should that affect anything?

See Answers

 
Related Questions

Investment question!


If you move money out of a 401k and into an ira and you make no changes to the stocks you...

 

Paying off loan by rolling over to 401k to ira


The sale of my company will be going through very soon. i already have a $2000 loan on my...

 

My new employer doesn't have a 401k. i already had a roth and an existing ira. which one should i fully fund now?


I was recently laid-off and my prospective employer doesn't currently offer a 401k (may...

 

Can my husband roll his 401k over into my 401k when he changes jobs? his new employer does not have a 401k.


My husband changed jobs a year ago and has funds in the old employer's 401k plan. his...

 

Sep ira, 401k


Hi, if my husband's ira he puts his kids name, and mine i put my kid's name, if one...

 

401k vs. roth ira?


If my employer matches up to 4% on their 401k and i want to invest 10% of my salary, am i...

 
 

See more 401k questions

 
 
 
 
 

Ask A Question

Ask a new question about
401k: