Welcome! | Ask A Question

 
 
 
 
Question

Asked 2/4/2009

Withdrawling money out of my 401k plan

What is the penalty for withdrawling money out of my 401k plan to pay off credit cards?

 
 
 
 
 
Answers

Answer 1/1 - Submitted 6/4/2010

Simple answer - probably more than the interest rates on your credit cards!

Assuming that all of the Contributions to your 401(k) were pre-tax, you will pay the highest marginal Tax rate on your Tax Return for the entire Distribution. You will have to talk to your Tax Advisor now (not during Tax Season) to get that most probable percentage.

Your company's Plan Sponsor will "help" (yes, I am being a little sarcastic by using the quotes) you on the Tax side by automatically deducting 20% and giving it to the Federal government before writing a check for what's left over to you.

If you are under 59 1/2 when you take the Distribution, you will also get hit with a 10% penalty for a Premature Distribution. I should also mention that there may or may not be a state and/or local Tax bite to worry about when you get your check and/or file your Tax Return.

An alternative to taking a Distribution (and accepting all of those Taxes/penalties) is to take a Loan from your 401(k) - if your Plan allows. Though I am not a fan of 401(k) Loans, it may be better than a Distribution.

Whether you take a Distribution or a Loan, you are still missing out on growth in your account as we crawl out of this 'Great Recession.' If you had taken money out shortly after you posted this question, you likely have already missed the 6-month 'correction' that saw the stock market pick up nearly half of the losses incurred from the stock market's peak just a couple years earlier.

Add the lost opportunity (and I expect more increases in the stock market since we are STILL not out of this recession) to the Taxes and Penalty, then compare it to your Credit Card rates. Hopefully, this may spur you to look elsewhere for funds (cutting down on spending, searching for unclaimed funds long ago turned over to the states, downsizing your lifestyle, adding side jobs for increased income, etc.) rather than at your 401(k) Plan.

On the other hand, you may have already tried these other paths and found them lacking. In which case, I wish you luck and good speed in continuing to seek out advice from all corners in this economy!

P.S.: Just to clarify, I don't expect credit cards will be as generous as they used to be with interest rates any time soon; nevertheless, there are still bargains out there if you are persistent (even in the credit market).

 
 
 
 
Answer This Question Now

Type your Answer in the box below and post your answer.

Learn more about how this works

 
 
 

Related Questions (Ask a New Question)

 
Does an employer have to match any amount of money in order for its plan to be called a 401k plan

I am in an employer sponsored 401k plan and they do not match or contribute any money toward it. a friend said to me that it is not a 401k plan without the employer matching some percentage of what i contribute. i do not believe the employer has to contribute anything. this is just to settle a friendly...

See Answers

 
Finding lost money through a company who took money out of my checks to put in a 401k plan

18 years ago i worked for a company who took money out of my paychecks to place in a 401k plan, how do i locate my funds?

See Answers

 
Can my employer force me into a 401k plan using my health and welfare benefits

Hello im a contracted armed guard for the federal goverment and im in a union i didn't ask for because i was satified with the international i had before , however my new company wants to take my health and welfare fund and put it into a 401k plan if i dont elect the out of pocket health plan they...

See Answers

 
Related Questions

Does an employer have to match any amount of money in order for its plan to be called a 401k plan


I am in an employer sponsored 401k plan and they do not match or contribute any money toward...

 

Finding lost money through a company who took money out of my checks to put in a 401k plan


18 years ago i worked for a company who took money out of my paychecks to place in a 401k...

 

Can my employer force me into a 401k plan using my health and welfare benefits


Hello im a contracted armed guard for the federal goverment and im in a union i didn't...

 

Can a person withdraw funds from thier 401k plan while still a participant who is not of retirement age?


I want to pull money from my 401k plan to pay down debt.possibly to make repairs to home. my...

 

I apparently am enrolled into a 401k plan that doesnt let me access my money, even in cases of hardship. what can i do?


My company has us in a 401k plan that doesn't let me access my money at any cost. im...

 

My husband has a 401k plan from a former employer that has $50k in it. he was told he needs to get the money out.


He was told on friday that he needs to make a decision monday (today) how to get his money...

 
 

See more 401k questions

 
 
 
 
 

Ask A Question

Ask a new question about
401k: